ADVERTISEMENT
I thought I was marrying into a family that had already survived its worst tragedy. Then, a small comment from my boyfriend Daniel’s eldest daughter made me realize that something was very strange in that house.
When I started dating Daniel, he said something that almost scared me completely on the second date.
“I have two daughters,” she told me. “Grace is six years old. Emily is four. Their mother died three years ago.”
He said it calmly, but I could hear the tension in his voice.
I reached across the table. “Thank you for telling me.”
It was easy to love the girls.
He gave me a tired smile. “Some people hear that and run away.”
“I’m still here.”
And he was.
The girls were easy to love. Grace was sharp and curious and always asked questions as if the world owed her answers. Emily was quieter. At first, she hid behind Daniel’s leg. A month later, she climbed onto my lap with a picture book as if she’d known me forever.
After the wedding, I moved into his house.
I never tried to replace her mother. I was simply there. I made grilled cheese. I watched cartoons. I endured fevers, craft disasters, and endless pretend play.
Daniel and I dated for a year before getting married.
We had a small wedding by a lake. Just family. Grace wore a flower crown and asked about the cake every ten minutes. Emily fell asleep before sunset. Daniel seemed happy, but cautious, as if he didn’t trust that happy things would last.
After the wedding, I moved into his house.
It seemed reasonable. So I went along with it.
It was warm and beautiful. Large kitchen. Wrap-around porch. Toys everywhere. Family photos on the walls.
And a closed basement door.
I realized it the first week.
“Why is it always closed?” I asked one night.
Daniel continued drying dishes. “Storage. A lot of junk. Old tools, boxes, things like that. I don’t want the girls to hurt themselves.”
It sounded reasonable. So I let it go.
Once I found Grace sitting on the hallway floor, staring at the doorknob.
Even so, I noticed things.
Sometimes Grace would look at the basement door when she thought no one could see her.
Sometimes Emily would stand near her for a second and then hurry away.
Once I found Grace sitting on the hallway floor, staring at the doorknob.
“What are you doing?” I asked him.
He looked up. “Nothing.”
Then came the day when everything changed.
And he ran away.
It was strange, but not strange enough to start a fight.
Then came the day when everything changed.
The two girls had slight colds, so I stayed home with them. They were glum for an hour, and then they turned into a noisy, sneezing chaos.
“I’m dying,” Grace announced from the sofa.
“Your nose is blocked,” I told him.
At noon they were playing hide-and-seek like little maniacs.
Emily sneezed onto a blanket. “I’m dying too.”
“Very tragic,” I said. “Drink your juice.”
At midday they were playing hide-and-seek like little maniacs.
“No running,” I told them.
They ran.
“No jumping off the furniture.”
Grace shouted from upstairs, “That was Emily!”
A chill ran through me.
Emily shouted, “I’m a baby! I don’t know the rules!”
I was heating up soup when Grace came into the kitchen and pulled at my sleeve.
He had a serious face.
“Do you want to meet my mom?”
I stared at her. “What?”
She nodded. “Do you want to meet my mom? She liked to play hide-and-seek too.”
My heart began to beat strongly.
A chill ran through me.
“Grace,” I said carefully, “what do you mean?”
She frowned. “Do you want to see where he lives?”
Emily came in behind her, dragging a stuffed rabbit by one ear.
“Mommy is downstairs,” he said.
My heart began to beat strongly.
Grace dragged me down the hall as if she were showing me a birthday surprise.
“Down where?” I asked.
Grace grabbed my hand. “In the basement. Let’s go.”
All the bad thoughts hit me at once.
The closed door. The secrecy. The girls’ stares. A dead wife. A basement that Daniel never opened in my presence.
Grace pulled me down the hall as if she were showing me a birthday surprise.
At the door, he looked at me and said, “You just have to open it.”
I should have waited. Now I know.
My mouth went dry. “Does Daddy take you down there?”
She nodded. “Sometimes. When he misses her.”
That didn’t help.
I tried the doorknob. It was closed.
Grace said, “It’s okay. Mommy’s there.”
I should have waited. Now I know.
A pungent smell hit me first.
Instead, I pulled two bobby pins out of my bun and knelt beside the padlock with trembling hands.
Emily was next to me, sniffling. Grace was bouncing on her toes.
The lock clicked.
I froze.
Grace whispered, “See?”
I opened the door.
The basement was dimly lit, but I could see enough.
First, I was hit by a pungent smell. Sour. Damp.
I went down one step, then another.
The basement was dimly lit, but I could see enough.
And then my fear changed.
It was not a body.
It wasn’t a hidden nightmare.
I stood there.
It was a sanctuary.
There was an old sofa with a blanket draped over one arm. Shelves full of photo albums. Framed photos of Daniel’s wife everywhere. Children’s drawings. Boxes labeled with black marker. A small tea set on a child-sized table. A cardigan draped over a chair. A pair of women’s rain boots against the wall. An old television next to stacks of DVDs.
The smell was of mold. A pipe was dripping into a bucket. The water had stained part of the wall.
Continue on next page
ADVERTISEMENT
