ADVERTISEMENT
Step-by-Step Directions (Super Simple, I Promise)
1. Heat the sugar and milk
I bring the sugar and milk to a boil in a medium pot. Try not to stare at it like I do (it kinda hypnotizes me), but keep the heat steady until it bubbles.
2. Let it cook a little
I keep it going for a few minutes — just enough for the mix to thicken a bit. Nothing fancy, you’ll just see it start to look a little richer.
3. Add the peanut butter, butter, and vanilla
Once the mix is hot and ready, I pull the pot off the heat. Then I toss in the peanut butter, butter, vanilla, and a tiny pinch of salt.
Everything melts together into this dreamy, creamy goodness. I seriously have to stop myself from “taste testing” half the pot.
4. Pour and chill
I pour the mixture into a lined dish (foil or parchment saves cleanup — trust me). Then I let it cool until firm.
If you’re impatient like me, you’ll probably keep poking it, asking, “Is it ready yet?” No shame.
Tips to Make It Faster (My Lazy-Day Tricks)
- Use a slightly wider pot — things warm quicker.
- Chill the dish ahead of time — makes it set sooner.
- Don’t skip the pinch of salt — seriously, it brings the flavor together.
- Cut it before it gets too firm — or you’ll end up sawing through it like you’re carving a tree stump. Been there.
Fun Ways to Switch It Up
Okay, I’m not saying you should get wild, but if you want to, here are some ideas I’ve tried:
- Add mini chocolate chips on top (they melt a bit and look cute).
- Sprinkle crushed pretzels for a salty crunch.
- Swirl in a little jelly — like a PB&J fudge moment.
- Mix in chopped peanuts if you like some texture.
Just don’t overthink it. This fudge pretty much always comes out good.
ADVERTISEMENT
